AllTrue was founded in 2014 as Causebox, a subscription box service built on a specific premise: that most people who care about sustainability don’t have time to research every purchase, and that curation could close the gap between values and behavior. The model has since expanded into an Essentials Market with over 700 ethically produced products available to members at up to 70% off retail.
The subscription box is the acquisition channel. The marketplace is where the model sustains itself.
What AllTrue Actually Offers
Each quarterly subscription box contains 6-8 full-sized products (clean beauty, ethical home goods, cruelty-free accessories) curated to demonstrate that sustainable living is aesthetically desirable rather than a sacrifice. The box value is consistently above $250; subscription pricing is lower. The gap between box value and subscription price is the discovery cost: AllTrue is essentially paying customers to try products that would otherwise require significant research to find.
This model serves a real consumer friction: sustainable products are often scattered across specialty retailers, difficult to compare, and hard to trust without context. AllTrue’s vetting process (brands must respect human rights, the environment, and workers’ rights, and meet documented manufacturing standards) does the trust work on behalf of members.
The Essentials Market converts subscription members into recurring purchasers. Once a customer has tried and liked a product from a quarterly box, they can replenish it through the marketplace at significant discount. This is a subscription model converted into a marketplace model, which changes the unit economics considerably.
The Curation Standard
AllTrue’s approach to brand selection is detailed and ongoing: brands pass a vetting process before inclusion, and the product curation team actively seeks items with documented social impact. The mix of categories (clean beauty, ethical homewares, fair trade accessories) is deliberate. It demonstrates that sustainable options exist across the full spectrum of everyday consumer purchases, which is a more effective behavior-change tool than any single sustainable category alone.
The Artist Residency program (where emerging female artists from California work with AllTrue’s design team on custom pieces) extends the brand’s values into the creator economy rather than just the producer supply chain. This is both a community investment and a way to generate genuinely unique products that members can’t find elsewhere.
The subscription box model’s sustainability value isn’t primarily about the products in the box. It’s about changing what customers default to on their next purchase — and whether the curated introduction creates a durable behavioral shift toward sustainable products.
The Discovery Challenge AllTrue Addresses
The actual problem AllTrue solves isn’t finding sustainable products: those exist in increasing abundance. It’s the cost of trust: for most sustainable product categories, determining whether a brand’s claims are real requires research time that most consumers don’t have.
AllTrue’s vetting function is a form of trust arbitrage: they invest the research time so subscribers don’t have to. The subscription model creates the revenue stream that funds continuous brand discovery and evaluation.
For retailers building sustainable product programs, this is an instructive model: curating sustainable options with transparent vetting criteria is more valuable to eco-conscious consumers than stocking sustainable options without any visible selection logic. The communication of how and why products were selected is part of the product.
Get your subscription at their website or follow them at Facebook and Instagram.
P.S. AllTrue’s Essentials Market is worth exploring even without a subscription box membership: the marketplace model makes sustainably sourced everyday essentials available at competitive prices, which is the access argument that AllTrue was founded on.